A few months a go some frum bloggers were patting themselves on their backs, in a self congratulatory way for a
historic meeting a groundbreaking meeting, known as the
Monsey summit . Its purpose was to identify problems within the frum orthodox Jewish community spend an experimental, intimate evening of discussion together. Each speaker identified a problem in the community, its negative consequences, and proposed improvements and solutions.
Eleven people were at the meeting five "
prominent" members from the orthodox community and five
"prominent" members of the formerly Orthodox Jewish community. The Orthodox members were from the non-Modern Orthodox, non-chasidic, non-Lakewood communities. Those who attended were, (in alphabetical order only dont know who the five and five are)
Rabbi Yitzchok Adlerstein, Ms. Avital Chizhik. Rabbi Ron Eisenman. Rabbi Aaron Fink, Eli Fink, Ms. Adina Kadden, Mr. Ushy Katz, Rabbi Avi Shafran, Ms. Frieda Vizel, Ms. Leah Vincent, Anonymous, Rabbi Yakov Hororwitz,was unable to attend simply because of a conflict.
What went on at the meeting is a state secret (
here is a
report from one of the OTD who attended.) only those who attended are privileged to that. What we do know is that a great chilul hashem has come out of this meeting.
Torah misinai, Frum Yidden are now being questioned of their practice and
emunah bahashem. The orthodox members who were there, listened to those that are no longer frum, explain the reasons why they left the fold.
Instead of standing up to the criticism of the orthodox frum community, they took what was said and are now writing articles attacking yiddishkeit. These articles, have generated debates which openly question
ikrei haemunah. Frum Yidden are now portrayed as
orthoprax , Harry the middle of the road blogger has opened the floodgates of koifrim and apikorsim to spew their hate against Torah Misinai R''L. The nation of
maaminim bnei maaminim has now become non believers r''l. Another wrote
Articles on staying frum that appear to be based on a warped view of the few he met that abandoned yiddishkeit.
Torah is Vibrant today, klal yisrael is strong. There are thousands of children learning, thousands of yidden serving hashem with emunah, doing mitzvos and maasim tovim. Its time to end all this madness, time for the skeptics to move away, time for these rabbis to get offline, to stop tweeting, and facebooking. Let us daven that hashem bring all his children back to him and we can all say in unison hashem echad ushmo echad.